MiniMania.com
NEED HELP?

Currency: 







 Newsletter Sign Up

Resources


News Highlights

Hooked On Minis: August 21st - Thunderhill Raceway

Source: hookedondriving.com
WE LOVE Minis!! Both classic and current - come join HOD...
Read more...

Electric MINI?

Source: Edmonds.com
BIRMINGHAM, Mich. - Mini plans to launch an all-electric car...
Read more...

MINI Sales UP!

by Evan McCausland
Need more proof that Americans are embracing small, fuel-efficient cars?..
Read more...
"Sizzling Remote Shifter. Any cures??
TOPIC:  

"Sizzling Remote Shifter. Any cures??

    Created by: dr dave
Orig. Posting Date User Name Edit Date Msg No.
Jun-02-2008 03:41PM karlos_junior Edited: Jun-16-2008 06:03PM   843501
Jun-02-2008 03:39PM karlos_junior   843499
May-17-2008 06:33AM xcc_rider   840505
May-16-2008 09:56PM dr dave   840480
May-16-2008 07:42PM xcc_rider   840465
May-16-2008 06:20PM dr dave   840453
May-16-2008 03:11PM xcc_rider   840430
May-15-2008 10:52PM dr dave   840247
May-05-2008 08:04PM karlos_junior   838332
May-05-2008 07:24AM xcc_rider   838168
May-04-2008 04:49PM karlos_junior   838090
Apr-29-2008 06:37AM xcc_rider Edited: Apr-29-2008 10:37AM   837266
Apr-28-2008 05:52AM Dean2   837091
Apr-28-2008 03:30AM 1963S   837078
Apr-27-2008 10:00AM Cup Cake   836958
Apr-27-2008 09:08AM Alex   836953
Apr-27-2008 05:37AM xcc_rider Edited: Apr-27-2008 05:50AM   836935
Apr-26-2008 07:16PM 66Cooper'S   836905
Apr-26-2008 07:12PM 66Cooper'S   836903
Apr-26-2008 07:05PM declanm   836900

 Forum Width:     Forum Type: 
Found 30 Messages   Page 1 of 2:     1 | 2 
You Must be logged in to reply to this topic You Must be logged in to create a new topic Login to message board
You Must be logged to add a favoriteMy Favorites List Return to Topic List
 Posted: Jun-02-2008 03:41PM
 Edited:  Jun-16-2008 06:03PM
karlos_junior
Total Posts: 4
Last Post: 06-02-08
Member Since: 05-04-08

 
Reply

hello everyone

I have just tried the "beer can" treatment on the nylon cup and its still sizzling like a "insert nasty word here"

 now I may have done this wrong, I placed the can shimmer UNDER the nylon cup to rase it up a fraction but not on the sides....

 should I wrap the aluminum around the inside of the cup>? sorry for all the silly questions but this rattle is really getting on my wick! and I dont want to put any undue vibration down on my new gear box.......

 

 Posted: Jun-02-2008 03:39PM
karlos_junior
Total Posts: 4
Last Post: 06-02-08
Member Since: 05-04-08

 
Reply

hello everyone

I have just tried the "beer can" treatment on the nylon cup and its still sizzling like a "insert nasty word here"

 now I may have donr this wring, I placed the can shimmer UNDER the nylon cup to rase it up a fraction but not on the sides.... should I wrap the aluminum aroun the cup>? sorry for all the silly questions but this rattle is really getting on my wick!....

 

 Posted: May-17-2008 06:33AM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply

Dave,  I read your post below about having the "older" style remote shifter and so I'm assuming you mean the 1st generation that doesn't have the nylon flange above the shifter arm ball. (see link below)

http://www.minimania.com/web/like/y/item/22G292/invDetail.cfm

If it does then you can try replacing that too. It holds the ball firmly into the housing eliminating the up-down movement of the ball which can make a nasty noise too. If not maybe you can find a newer style 2nd generation housing and upgrade. I figure there's always a reason for it when old designs are replaced with newer ones.  I think Pixieracing or Smurf has one listed in one of their for sale posts.    dan 

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: May-16-2008 09:56PM
dr dave
Total Posts: 293
Last Post: 08-15-08
Member Since: 10-28-99

 
Reply
Dan, I'll order a new spring, as I've just replaced both the cup and the plunger with new items.

dr dave

This just in......Red Stripe Beer makes you Stupic.

 Posted: May-16-2008 07:42PM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply

Dr D, when you screwed the "bolt" that holds the spring and plunger in did you feel considerable resistance?  You may have to stretch the spring a bit to restore it to original length. It should hold the shaft firmly with firm resistance when moved through the shifting pattern.

If it meets the above conditions and you still have unwanted "loose" movement then it's probably the nylon cup that is worn out and you can try the beer can shim trick. I didn't have to and re-used the old cup with no problems.     dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: May-16-2008 06:20PM
dr dave
Total Posts: 293
Last Post: 08-15-08
Member Since: 10-28-99

 
Reply
I found the spring on the floor. Still rattling though not as bad. As scary as the beer can thing is, It's looking like it's worth a try.

dr dave

This just in......Red Stripe Beer makes you Stupic.

 Posted: May-16-2008 03:11PM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply

Dr, I got my spring and plunger from our host.   Now that it's back on the road there no vibration and a stiffer shifting pattern.    dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: May-15-2008 10:52PM
dr dave
Total Posts: 293
Last Post: 08-15-08
Member Since: 10-28-99

 
Reply
Finally took it apart tonight. I went to install a brand new anti rattle plunger (#17). After taking out the spring retainer cup it appears there was no plunger, and no spring (#18). Hopefully someone has a spring in stock. I hope that will take care of it.

dr dave

This just in......Red Stripe Beer makes you Stupic.

 Posted: May-05-2008 08:04PM
karlos_junior
Total Posts: 4
Last Post: 06-02-08
Member Since: 05-04-08

 
Reply
well after further investigation it seem I dont have a "24 - gear seat" I got the older type "10 - 11"  but spose the shiming is the same.

 Posted: May-05-2008 07:24AM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply
That's it just shim around the barrel of the insert. Order the anti-rattle plunger also. It's a little brass plug that fits on the end of the spring. Mine had a big groove worn into it allowing the shifter rod to vibrate.  Replacing it really stiffened up the shifting also.   dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: May-04-2008 04:49PM
karlos_junior
Total Posts: 4
Last Post: 06-02-08
Member Since: 05-04-08

 
Reply

hi, thanks for this topic its proving to be full of real awesome ideas, Im going to give the beer can repair a go but just want to double check I have my new to this wee head around it...

is this the part I wish to "beer can repair"

2422G389 Gearlever seat 1

 

thanks in advance, going to replace the anti rattle spring as well but like the idea of taking that 1-2mm "travel" out of the gearstick.

 Posted: Apr-29-2008 06:37AM
 Edited:  Apr-29-2008 10:37AM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply

I am brain dead today as I slept in and haven't had any coffee yet but someone here on the board had a similar problem with a ball shaped item that they welded up and filed to the correct dimentions and it worked fine. I remember it because I have the same problem with the same part and the replacement was NLA or major $$$ but for the life of me I can't remember what it is right now.

Gotta make some coffee!!!!    dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: Apr-28-2008 05:52AM
Dean2
Total Posts: 2303
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 12-07-00

 
Reply

Thanks for asking about this.  I've been meaning to do so for a while.

When I put my linkage together, I used the least worn parts from three sets.  All of the balls and female joints were at least somewhat worn.  Can the balls be welded and reground with good results?

Thanks to the Interstate Highway System, it is now possible to travel from coast to coast without seeing anything.
Charles Kuralt

Autox/Rallyx Videos

 Posted: Apr-28-2008 03:30AM
1963S
Total Posts: 405
Last Post: 08-19-08
Member Since: 09-21-06

 
Reply
If you want to keep the original appearance (and assuming that there's no abnormal wear) just shove a Morris Minor front trunnion bush over the lower end of the lever (brim up - you'll see what I mean once you get hold of the bush).

Guaranteed sizzle stopper.

Cheers, Ian

 Posted: Apr-27-2008 10:00AM
Cup Cake
Total Posts: 5235
Last Post: 08-21-08
Member Since: 05-13-01

 
Reply
Alex. Do as I say to solve the 'sizzle'. You didn't need to buy new bits. I did everything I could think of until CTR put me onto the solution. If you look at most Works rally cars you'll see a sleeve on the shifter which is the way Abingdon solved the problem.

 Posted: Apr-27-2008 09:08AM
Alex
Total Posts: 5636
Last Post: 08-21-08
Member Since: 03-24-99

 
Reply
I've just re-read the original post as well, and it does sound like the top nylon washer thingie is worn.

Having said that, mine still vibrated like a bugger with new top & bottom nylon cups.

The half moon seals are readily available - 22A285.

Metric is for people who can't do fractions.

 Posted: Apr-27-2008 05:37AM
 Edited:  Apr-27-2008 05:50AM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1006
Last Post: 08-20-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Reply

I re-read the post and thought about the up and down movement more, it could be the nylon spacer ring is worn/missing and allows the ball to move up and down also. Check things out after you take the shifter boot off and as you disassemble it to see exactly what is allowing the movement. These nylon bits start to get expensive if you're throwing parts at it.

John, where were you when I had mine all apart?  Those are great ideas to modify the housing. I'll have to add it to my "To Do" list for the next time.   And remember to make sure you have the half moon seal installed or it will look like this----->     Lots of gravel and grease to make things interesting.

You can use silicone in place of the front top seal as I haven't seen one of these yet on anybody's website.   dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: Apr-26-2008 07:16PM
66Cooper'S
Total Posts: 2451
Last Post: 08-21-08
Member Since: 02-26-99

 
Reply
As well as drill and tap the front of the casing and put a grease fitting there as well.  This will allow you to lubricate the front and the rear "bearing surfaces" that the gear change shaft slide on without removing the shaft.

 Posted: Apr-26-2008 07:12PM
66Cooper'S
Total Posts: 2451
Last Post: 08-21-08
Member Since: 02-26-99

 
Reply
You could drill and tap the spring retaining cap ( #20 ) and put a grease fitting on it.  Also drill a small hole in the anti rattle plunger ( #17 ).

 Posted: Apr-26-2008 07:05PM
declanm
Total Posts: 362
Last Post: 08-21-08
Member Since: 04-08-08

 
Reply
in addition to the other suggestions, you might get some skilled help that can shim or replicate the worn bits and spring if a new spring isn't available

You Must be logged in to reply to this topic You Must be logged in to create a new topic Login to message board
You Must be logged to add a favoriteMy Favorites List Return to Topic List
Found 30 Messages   Page 1 of 2:     1 | 2 
Mini Cooper Part-G2NMI6001 MANN INTERIOR CABIN FILTER - MINI COOPER AND S Aftermarket replacement Cabin Filter for your 2007+ R56 MINI Cooper and Cooper S, and for your 2008+ R55 MINI Cooper and Cooper S CLUBMAN. Select Standard Paper or Charcoal Activated Filter from [ More Info]

On SALE: $23.95
List Price: $26.95

Type options available
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-NMW3074 PIAA EURO TECH VINTAGE WHEELS EACH - 17 X 7 ET45 17 LBS EURO TECH VINTAGE PIAA WHEELS Racing Buff finish with clear coat. Retro Look
Fits MINI Cooper and Cooper S (M12 and M14 bolts)
Lightweight
1-Piece Pressure Cast
[ More Info]

On SALE: $279.00
List Price: $299.00
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-NMK3220 BRAKE MAINTENANCE 'PLUS' RED KIT - MINI COOPER AND S While typical brake maintenance is limited to new pads, the best solution is to replace both the pads and rotors. This handy kit includes upgraded aftermarket rotors and pads. The brake pads [ More Info]

On SALE: $429.95
List Price: $439.95
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-G2NMK1056 MINI COOPER OIL FILTER REPLACEMENT MANN W/GSKT 4-PAK Replacement MANN Oil Filter with the O-ring and crush washer for the drain plug 4-PAK . Fits your 2007+ R56 MINI Cooper and Cooper S, and 2008+ R55 MINI Cooper and Cooper S CLUBMAN. En [ More Info]

On SALE: $35.95
List Price: $40.95